![]()
2
b. Whether the Claimant Order established the personal liability of the
Appellant to each of Petitioning Creditors and foreclosed any bona fide
disputes as to the validity or amount of the alleged debts?
c. Whether District Court Docket 987 stayed, pending appeal, the Claimant
Order and therefore renders the Petitioning Creditors’ claims subject to a bona
fide dispute?
e. Whether the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals stayed the Claimant Order
through findings set out and specifically articulated in its Opinion and Order
of December 18, 2012 and therefore renders the Petitioning Creditors’ claims
subject to a bona fide dispute?
f. Whether the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Order of November 9, 2012
and/or December 31, 2012 stayed the Claimant Order and therefore renders
the Petitioning Creditors’ claims subject to a bona fide dispute?
g. Whether res judicata bars Appellant’s bona fide disputes as to the
Petitioning Creditors’ claims because no final determination was made of
either the liability or amount of the claims against Appellant?
h. Whether collateral estoppel bar’s Appellants bona fide disputes as to the
Petitioning Creditors’ claims because the “facts” determined were not
essential to the order, and because the order was not fully and fairly litigated.
2. Whether the bankruptcy court erred in ruling that res judicata bars Appellant from
establishing a bona fide dispute as to the claims of the Petitioning Creditors?
3. Whether the bankruptcy court erred in ruling that collateral estoppel bars
Appellant from establishing a bona fide dispute as to the claims of the Petitioning
Creditors?
4. Whether the Fifth Circuit decision dated December 18, 2012 was res judicata and/or
collaterally estopped re-litigation of Petitioning Creditors’ claim that Docket 575 had
“not been reduced to judgment”, the current and former lawyers were “nonjudgment
creditors” who sought to recover on “unsecured claims…that had not been reduced to
judgment” and therefore not a final judgment on the merits?
5. Whether an order that was part of a vacated receivership proceeding can serve as a
basis for collateral estoppel or res judicata in subsequent proceedings?
6. Whether Petitioning Creditors’ Petition was barred and should have been
dismissed as a result of District Court’s Receivership Order?
Case 12-37921-sgj7 Doc 157 Filed 05/03/13 Entered 05/03/13 15:59:17 Desc Main
Document Page 2 of 4